It didn’t take long after Brat for the obvious question to show up: what does Charli XCX do when the big neon pop moment has already happened? For me, Music, Fashion, Film is interesting because it refuses the easy answer. Instead of trying to outdo Brat on volume or club energy, Charli spends 2026 making a shorter, guitar-driven pop record that sounds a little scrappier, a little more suspicious of its own fame, and a lot less interested in giving us a clean victory lap. I like that choice. I also think it’s why the album is at its best when it sounds agile and a little mean, and less convincing when the concept starts showing through the seams.
The post-Brat reset
The first thing that changes is the frame. This album is described in the critical run as rock-, punk-, or guitar-leaning rather than club-pop or electronic, and that reads true right away. “Rock Music,” the 1:55 opener, gets in and out fast, built on buzzy guitar and a beat that feels intentionally plain compared to the rush Charli chased on Brat. Around the one-minute mark, the track feels like it should explode into a bigger pop release, but it holds its line instead. That restraint ends up defining the record. Even when the hooks are obvious, the production keeps sanding off the big dancefloor payoff.
That’s the key difference from Brat: this isn’t a total reinvention, and it doesn’t pretend to be. The hooks are still there, the personality is still there, and the contrarian streak is still doing a lot of the heavy lifting. But the album keeps pushing those instincts through guitars, simpler rhythms, and shorter song forms. That makes some of these tracks feel closer in spirit to the directness of Sucker than the club-pop glare of 1999, while still keeping a little of the quick, first-thought intimacy people often attach to how i’m feeling now.
The songs that make the pivot work
The strongest argument for the album is that the standout tracks actually justify the switch in style. The album includes “Rock Music,” “2007,” and “Camera,” and those three songs do most of the heavy lifting in explaining what Charli is after here. “Camera” is maybe the sharpest of the bunch. At 2:31, it’s compact even by this album’s standards, and that helps. The guitars don’t crowd the song; they jab at it. The beat stays simple, which puts extra pressure on the vocal phrasing and the hook, and Charli responds by sounding more clipped and self-aware than lush or carefree.
“2007” is the album’s most obvious candy rush, but even there the record keeps one foot on the brake. It plays with nostalgia in a way that recalls “1999,” except it’s less broad and less eager to turn memory into a party trick. “SS26” also deserves some credit here: at 2:46, it gives the record one of its cleaner pop structures, but the arrangement still feels wiry rather than polished to death. And “Card Declined,” at 3:28 one of the longer cuts, benefits from that extra space. It lands harder because Charli lets the tension sit for a few more bars instead of racing to the next idea.
Fame, image, and Charli as a character
A lot of pop records about fame collapse under their own thesis. Music, Fashion, Film mostly avoids that by staying petty, funny, and specific in tone, even when the larger subject is celebrity machinery. That’s where the album’s self-mythology works for me. Charli doesn’t sound like she’s delivering a grand statement about stardom so much as she’s poking at the ugly little rituals that come with being watched, packaged, and copied. The title alone points in that direction, but the songs are stronger when they keep that pressure close to the body rather than turning it into theory.
This is also why the album feels like a real post-Brat move instead of a cosmetic pivot. Brat was built to hit hard and fast. This one often withholds that release on purpose, which can be frustrating, but it fits the subject. Charli sounds aware that public image has turned into part of the product, and she uses that awareness as both a shield and a joke. There’s continuity with True Romance and how i’m feeling now in that sense: she’s still diaristic in flashes, still blunt, still restless, but now the performance of being Charli XCX is one of the main themes rather than just the vehicle.
Where it bites hardest, and where it feels too managed
My main reservation is that the album can feel a little over-managed. That’s not the same as saying it’s cold. In fact, part of its appeal is how brisk and funny it can be. But there are stretches where the prickliness starts to feel less like instinct and more like strategy. The record has been praised for being catchy and candid, and I hear that, but I also hear the packaged-statement criticism. Sometimes the album seems very aware of how its pivot will be read: post-Brat, less euphoric, more guitar-led, more resistant. When that self-awareness stays light on its feet, it’s exciting. When it stiffens up, the songs can feel like they’re proving a point.
Still, I’d rather hear Charli make a sharp left turn than chase another obvious win. At 11 tracks, the album benefits from not overstaying its idea. The shorter runtimes on songs like “Rock Music” and “2007” help keep the whole thing moving, and even the weaker moments are rarely dull. The best parts of Music, Fashion, Film suggest a version of guitar-driven pop that doesn’t deny Charli’s pop instincts; it just puts them under harsher light. I wouldn’t put it above Brat, and I don’t think it reaches the raw immediacy of how i’m feeling now, but it earns its place in the catalog by refusing to behave like a sequel. Call it a solid 8/10.
If you want to hear Charli XCX test how far her hooks can travel once the club lights are off, give it a listen.
Tracklist
- Rock Music 1:55
- SS26 2:46
- Card Declined 3:28
- Camera 2:31
- 2007 2:04
- I’m Afraid 2:11
- Yeah 2:07
- Wink Wink 2:03
- Persona 2:37
- Magic Metal Montana 2:31
- No One Lasts Forever 3:06